Are Markets Repugnant?
- Type: seminar
- Semester: WS 17/18
- Start: Introductory meeting: 17.10.2017, 11.30 – 12.30 h, 01.93, K1
Jannis Engel, David Huber
- Lv-No.: 2560140
- Exam: Midterm presentations: 19.01.2018. Deadline for papers: 11.03.2018.
Application is possible via the centralized platform "Seminarportal " until September 16, 2017.
Full participation in the introductory meeting as well as in the presentation day in January is obligatory for successful participation!
Many societies have markets and areas of commerce that are deemed unethical or questionable by parts of their population. Alvin Roth coined the term repugnant markets for these not completely accepted or even illegal markets. The reasons for declaring certain market activities repugnant are manifold and often differ between societies and change over time. One example of such a change in perception is money lending, which was heavily restricted in medieval times but is indispensable for any capitalist society. On the other hand, the market for slaves and indentured servitude were both once very common, but any engagement in those markets is now unthinkable. A prominent, modern example is organ trade. While it is allowed to donate a kidney or half a liver, the sale of the very same organs remains illegal in most countries.
Inspirations and areas of topics can be, but are not limited to:
- Organ markets
- Private security firms / mercenaries
- Paid surrogate motherhood
- Prediction markets
- Drug markets
- Blood diamonds and conflict minerals
- Food speculations
- Privatization of water
- (Un)limited betting
There furthermore exist many more markets which might be deemed repugnant by many, but are nevertheless thriving because they remain out of the focus of attention.
Scope of the Seminar
In this seminar, participants prepare and hold a presentation about a repugnant or otherwise problematic market of their choice and hand in a seminar paper at the end of the semester. The talk and the paper should be used to describe the market of interest as well as its relevance, problems and implications.
Please note that no topics will be handed out by the seminar facilitators. Instead, participants will choose and present their market of interest.
The introductory meeting will take place on 17 October 2017. Students will work in pairs. If the process of pairing up remains unsuccessful, a partner will be assigned. In case of an uneven number of attendants one group of three will be possible.
On January 19, we will have a full day of presentations. These presentations should have a duration of 15 - 20 minutes and the speaking duration should be equally split among the presenters. The subsequent discussion should be used to give substantial feedback to the presenters. Full attendance is required on that day for successful participation in the seminar!
Seminar papers of 10 - 12 pages (plus references) have to be handed in by 11 March 2018.
For bachelor students grades will be based on the quality of presentations in the seminar (50%) and the seminar paper (50%).
Master students additionally have to hand in two abstracts with their paper. Their grades will be based on the quality of presentations in the seminar (40%), the seminar paper (40%) and the two abstracts (20%) – one with a maximum length of 100 words and one with a maximum length of 250 words.
Both Bachelor and Master students can improve their grades by 0.3 for good and constructive discussion contributions or by 0.7 for excellent and constructive discussion contributions.
Further Literature and Inspirations
See the work of, e.g., Thomas von Aquin, Björn Bartling, Samuel Bowles, Jannis Engel, Armin Falk, Martin Luther, Bettina Rockenbach, Alvin Roth, Michael Sandel, Andrei Shleifer, Georg Simmel, Joel Sobel, Nora Szech.